marjoleink on identi.ca

This remote profile is registered on another site; see marjoleink's original profile page on identi.ca.

1. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:29:31 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • zotz
   @zotz true. Provided the author is actually known, which in the case of PD is not necessarily the case.
2. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:28:39 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • rysiek
   @rysiek I ddi look at ALL sources provided in this thread. Precious few referring to 'Author's rights' that is.
3. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:26:49 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • rysiek
   @rysiek you are wrong in assuming I did not do what you suggest
4. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:23:53 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • rysiek
   :) no feet, let alone stomping involved. That's all exclusively in your imagination.
5. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:22:58 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • lxoliva
   @lxoliva so what?
6. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:19:31 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • lxoliva
   @lxoliva I deny that I am the only one who could possibly sell photographs of windows in Karakul (even if there were any buyers)
7. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:16:04 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • zotz
   I do NOT claim (nor ever will) a 'monopoly' in the market for photographs of windows in Karakul, even though I do claim my photos are unique
8. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:14:24 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • rysiek
   @rysike the more specific, the less it is a 'monopoly'. 'Apples', yes.- Apples grown in one specific orchard, no.
9. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:13:00 EDT marjoleink

   Remote profile options...

   • rysiek
   I conclude that both 1. and 2. are irrelevant. I make unique photographs but do not have a monopoly on such photographs.
10. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:11:50 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...
    ...but I do not have a monopoly in even in something as narrow as 'photographs taken on Karakul', let alone a wider category
11. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:10:41 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    2. 'If entity X has monopoly in apples, the fact that I can buy oranges instead of apples does not change the fact that X has a monopoly.'..
12. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:10:16 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek 1. is 'thesaurusally' a word? how does this apply at all to Dutch Author's right?
13. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:07:11 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek no, ANYone I grant the right to sell my work - not just me. Even if I do want to sell my own work AS WELL.
14. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 16:04:44 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek no, it is not!
15. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:51:05 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek no need for stomping feet, because where there is no 'market' in the true sense, 'monopoly' does not apply.
16. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:50:18 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek indeed. E.g., I have copyright to my letters to my mum & dad - but I regard that more as a matter of privacy.
17. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:46:39 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek no, that's not what copyright (as 'author's right') is about. it's about distribution.
18. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:45:01 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • rysiek
    @rysiek 'monopoly' applies to a 'market'. What a single producer/creator has to offer is not a 'market'.
19. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:40:42 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • zotz
    @zotz in a very narrow field the concept of 'market' becomes essentially meaningless.
20. marjoleink (marjoleink)'s status on Thursday, 11-Oct-2012 15:40:05 EDT marjoleink

    Remote profile options...

    • zotz
    @zotz so do I!

• After
• Before