Conversation:

Notices

1. laurelrusswurm (laurelrusswurm)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 13:12:54 EDT laurelrusswurm

   Remote profile options...

   • greg
   @greg Frankly, although they are not free enough, NC and ND *do* promote the commons because it allows creators to try !CC with less fear.
   • mjjzf (mjjzf)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 13:28:24 EDT mjjzf

     Remote profile options...

     • laurelrusswurm
     @laurelrusswurm !CC is a fairly wide spectrum. There is a tendency to talk about CC licensing as if homogenous.
   • laurelrusswurm (laurelrusswurm)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 13:44:30 EDT laurelrusswurm

     Remote profile options...

     • mjjzf
     @mjjzf Yes, and the suggestion is to remove NC and ND from that spectrum, which I believe would catastrphically harm !cc #StillTooNew
   • lxoliva (lxoliva)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 15:06:41 EDT lxoliva

     Remote profile options...

     • laurelrusswurm
     @laurelrusswurm like, with NC and ND, opponents need not embrace and extend !CC to keep their power, it's already done it to itself
   • lxoliva (lxoliva)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 15:09:10 EDT lxoliva

     Remote profile options...

     • laurelrusswurm
     @laurelrusswurm NC and ND promote the part of CC that's actually against the commons
   • vlax (vlax)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 15:14:48 EDT vlax

     Remote profile options...

     • lxoliva
     @lxoliva +1
   • zotz (zotz)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 19:42:39 EDT zotz

     Remote profile options...

     • laurelrusswurm
     I think mixing the Free and non-Free under one banner harms CC and betrays the idea of a creative *commons*
   • zotz (zotz)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 19:58:36 EDT zotz

     Remote profile options...

     • mjjzf
     and this is a big problem
   • lxoliva (lxoliva)'s status on Monday, 27-Aug-2012 21:12:23 EDT lxoliva

     Remote profile options...

     • zotz
     ♻ @zotz: I think mixing the Free and non-Free under one banner harms CC and betrays the idea of a creative *commons*
   • mjjzf (mjjzf)'s status on Tuesday, 28-Aug-2012 06:29:56 EDT mjjzf

     Remote profile options...

     • zotz
     Completely agree. I find it problematic when the Free-as-in-Freedom mindset is clamped over the CC spectrum with "accepted licenses".