@archaeme @bob Sorry, it took me a bit to grep the relevant bit out of the logs (mine are huge, forgot to set up logrotate.d on the new box)

But here's the relevant bit if someone can pass it on to Bob:

2016-12-11 09:58:40 LOG_ERR: [community.highlandarrow.com:25184.19ed9d28 GET /api/statuses/public_timeline.json?since_id=473698&_=1481104784232] HTTPClient: HTTP POST https://gnusocial.freedombone.net/main/push/callback/19 - Unable to connect to ssl://gnusocial.freedombone.net:443. Error: stream_socket_client(): unable to connect to ssl://gnusocial.freedombone.net:443 (Unknown error)
stream_socket_client(): Failed to enable crypto
stream_socket_client(): Peer certificate CN=`blog.freedombone.net' did not match expected CN=`gnusocial.freedombone.net'

Looks like its returning the blog cert for GS instead of GS'?